4 messages in com.googlegroups.bloggerdevRe: comment creation and authentication
FromSent OnAttachments
adamthehutt24 Jul 2007 10:55 
Pete Hopkins ☠26 Jul 2007 10:00 
adamthehutt26 Jul 2007 14:31 
Pete Hopkins ☠27 Jul 2007 10:50 
Subject:Re: comment creation and authentication
From:adamthehutt (adam@gmail.com)
Date:07/26/2007 02:31:02 PM
List:com.googlegroups.bloggerdev

Thanks for the reply. Does anyone know if Google plans to fix this? I can't imagine a scenario in which someone would benefit from the current implementation.

On Jul 26, 1:00 pm, "Pete Hopkins ☠" <phop@google.com> wrote:

On 7/24/07, adamthehutt <adam@gmail.com> wrote:

Hi,

I'm a new user of the Blogger Data API, and I'm a little confused about the API for comment creation. The protocol docs say:

"Note: Currently, you can only post comments to a blog owned by the authenticated user."

Which, along with the example provided, suggest that you can only really post comments under your own name/account to a blog that you own. This seems kind of useless to me... Wouldn't it make more sense to do one or the other? In other words, you can post under any name to a blog that you own, or you post under your own name (i.e. google account) to a blog owned by anyone?

Am I understanding this correctly? If so, can someone explain the rationale of this approach? Are there any plans to change it?

You're correct. The comment posting API via GData is not tremendously useful in its present state.

-- Pete