atom feed61 messages in org.freebsd.freebsd-questionsRe: ip masquerading
FromSent OnAttachments
Clint MarekMay 16, 1996 8:02 pm 
Doug WhiteMay 17, 1996 11:33 am 
Tony KimballMay 17, 1996 2:11 pm 
Terry LambertMay 17, 1996 2:23 pm 
Tony KimballMay 17, 1996 6:04 pm 
Archie CobbsMay 17, 1996 6:05 pm 
Terry LambertMay 17, 1996 6:13 pm 
Tony KimballMay 17, 1996 7:46 pm 
Terry LambertMay 17, 1996 10:48 pm 
Archie CobbsMay 18, 1996 1:23 am 
francis yeungMay 18, 1996 5:26 am 
Bruce A. MahMay 18, 1996 8:43 am 
Eric J. SchwertfegerMay 18, 1996 11:06 am 
Stephen HoveyMay 18, 1996 11:59 am 
Archie CobbsMay 18, 1996 1:05 pm 
Terry LambertMay 18, 1996 3:15 pm 
Clint MarekMay 18, 1996 10:09 pm 
Michael SmithMay 18, 1996 10:36 pm 
Tony KimballMay 19, 1996 12:50 am 
Carl MakinMay 19, 1996 5:01 am 
Pedro A M VazquezMay 19, 1996 6:01 am 
Michael SmithMay 19, 1996 7:40 am 
Charlie ROOTMay 19, 1996 4:37 pm 
Michael SmithMay 19, 1996 7:07 pm 
Garrett WollmanMay 20, 1996 7:40 am 
Bruce A. MahMay 20, 1996 8:37 am 
Tony KimballMay 20, 1996 11:48 am 
Jim DennisMay 20, 1996 12:47 pm 
Garrett WollmanMay 20, 1996 1:29 pm 
Tony KimballMay 20, 1996 1:36 pm 
Terry LambertMay 20, 1996 3:22 pm 
Terry LambertMay 20, 1996 3:28 pm 
Terry LambertMay 20, 1996 3:32 pm 
Gary PalmerMay 20, 1996 3:34 pm 
Archie CobbsMay 20, 1996 3:42 pm 
Terry LambertMay 20, 1996 3:45 pm 
Terry LambertMay 20, 1996 3:56 pm 
Terry LambertMay 20, 1996 4:15 pm 
Tony KimballMay 20, 1996 4:54 pm 
Tony KimballMay 20, 1996 5:09 pm 
Bruce A. MahMay 20, 1996 5:10 pm 
Bruce A. MahMay 20, 1996 5:23 pm 
Tony KimballMay 20, 1996 5:25 pm 
Michael SmithMay 20, 1996 6:38 pm 
Terry LambertMay 20, 1996 6:47 pm 
Jim DennisMay 20, 1996 8:13 pm 
Tony KimballMay 20, 1996 8:24 pm 
Jim DennisMay 20, 1996 9:14 pm 
Terry LambertMay 20, 1996 9:30 pm 
Terry LambertMay 20, 1996 9:34 pm 
Tony KimballMay 20, 1996 10:02 pm 
Bruce A. MahMay 20, 1996 10:12 pm 
Bruce A. MahMay 20, 1996 10:44 pm 
Tony KimballMay 20, 1996 10:47 pm 
M.R.MurphyMay 21, 1996 5:59 am 
Carl MakinMay 21, 1996 6:46 am 
Terry LambertMay 21, 1996 10:40 am 
Terry LambertMay 21, 1996 10:45 am 
Scott BlachowiczMay 22, 1996 9:28 am 
Pedro A M VazquezMay 22, 1996 11:13 am 
Bill FennerMay 22, 1996 11:45 am 
Subject:Re: ip masquerading
From:Archie Cobbs (arc@whistle.com)
Date:May 17, 1996 6:05:47 pm
List:org.freebsd.freebsd-questions

Is ip masquerading available for FreeBSD? I would like to route my Amiga (via NetBSD/ethernet) through my PC (FreeBSD), and I only have one IP address. I had this set up in Linux, but after I had a disk crash (which I don't think was Linux-related) I would like to give FreeBSD a try. If there is no masquerading availabe, is it being worked on?

AFAIK, FreeBSD doesn't provide this capability. I doubt it ever will, sinc IP masqerading was considered "evil" by some of the group :-)

Actually, the only people who believe that it is evil are those of us who believe FreeBSD should comply with IETF standards so that the backbone routers don't refuse to connect us to the Internet.

Which is to say, everyone who understands the problem.

Hmmm... guess I don't understand the problem. :-)

Just to make sure we're talking about the same thing, ``masquerading'' means using remapped TCP and UDP port numbers to facilitate internal hosts connecting to external servers, even though you only have one machine really talking to the Internet. You give all of the outgoing packets the same IP address but remap their source ports so when traffic comes back you know who it is really destined for, do the reverse mapping, etc..

Now, as far as the rest of the Internet is concerned, it just looks like your one IP address happens to be generating a lot of traffic, no? At least under the (not always valid) assumption that you don't run out of ports in your remapping range. What standards in particular are you referring to?

Of course, some protocols (which embed address information in the packets, like FTP) will not work through this kind of hackery without even more hackery, but at least it provides a capability to certain folks who didn't have it before. Seems like it would be one's own business whether they did masquerading or not.

-Archie