9 messages in org.apache.jakarta.slide-devRe: proposal to move JCR RI to incubator| From | Sent On | Attachments |
|---|---|---|
| Roy T. Fielding | 03 Aug 2004 17:30 | |
| Gianugo Rabellino | 04 Aug 2004 01:15 | |
| Daniel Florey | 04 Aug 2004 01:52 | |
| Daniel Florey | 04 Aug 2004 01:58 | |
| Mats Norén | 04 Aug 2004 04:22 | |
| Stefan Guggisberg | 04 Aug 2004 06:13 | |
| David Nuescheler | 05 Aug 2004 03:01 | |
| Paul Russell | 05 Aug 2004 04:06 | |
| Andrew Savory | 06 Aug 2004 03:43 |
| Subject: | Re: proposal to move JCR RI to incubator |
|---|---|
| From: | Daniel Florey (dflo...@apache.org) |
| Date: | 08/04/2004 01:52:05 AM |
| List: | org.apache.jakarta.slide-dev |
Gianugo Rabellino schrieb:
Therefore, I am proposing that the jcrri code be moved out of Slide and into the incubator as its own subproject, with explicit encouragement of anyone who wants to work on JCR itself to join that project as well.
I hear/share all your concerns and in general I welcome your proposal, but OTOH I do have some as well.
1. slide dependancy: I understand that the jcrri code has still quite a bit to do with slide, which is used as a backend (please correct me if I'm wrong). How would this affect the development process for all the stuff which doesn't clearly belong to slide or jcrri but affects both?
As far as I know jcrri has no dependencies to slide at all. It's not using Slide as a backend.
2. project scope. We all know that Tomcat is a RI as well, but its success has gone far beyond that. I would welcome jcrri as an Apache effort if the project scope is making a worthwile, performant and stable ASF-licensed implementation out of it, something that can be used in production: if, on the contrary, this impl is meant just as a barebone spec ri, it's still a very nice thing to have, but it could probably keep on living on slide as a more or less visible subproject.
As a consequence, then, my first proposal would be rethink the name: jcr or jcrri aren't "product" names, and they smell bad of "just" RI (a quick "grep '.*j.*c.*r.*' /usr/share/dict/words" didn't blow my mind, the best alternative being "rejoicer".
Likewise, if you are already a Slide or other Apache project committer, please let me know if you would like to be added to the list of initial committers.
Count me in, I'd be glad to help out in my Copious Free Time (urgh).
Ciao,