6 messages in edu.ku.nhm.mailman.taxacomSpirit Collections
FromSent OnAttachments
John SimmonsAug 25, 1995 12:18 am 
Alan HarveyAug 25, 1995 12:29 pm 
T.K. WilsonAug 25, 1995 1:42 pm 
Darrel E. SnyderAug 25, 1995 3:15 pm 
Jo...@Mizzou1.Missouri.edu C@Mizzou1.Missouri.edu Kingston@Mizzou1.Missouri.edu, BIOLOGIST@Mizzou1.Missouri.edu, Denver@Mizzou1.Missouri.edu, CO (John Kingston)Aug 25, 1995 6:06 pm 
Karsten HartelAug 26, 1995 8:37 am 
Actions with this message:
Paste this link in email or IM:
Paste this link in email or IM:
Atom feed for this thread
Paste this URL into your reader:
Subject:Spirit CollectionsActions...
From:John Simmons (JSIM@KUHUB.CC.UKANS.EDU)
Date:Aug 25, 1995 12:18:43 am
List:edu.ku.nhm.mailman.taxacom

Regarding the recent inquiries about substitutes for formaldehyde in fixation and preservation--in short, there aren't any good substitutes. Formaldehyde is a good to excellent preservative for most tissues, but not a good preservative for most tissues (there are exceptions, of course). Formaldehyde safety regs are not that hard to deal with--there are formaldehyde resistant gloves, tyvek aprons, and respirators on the market.

Ethylene glycol (a component of Caro-safe) is not really that safe. It can be absorbed through the skin and is toxic. There can be concentation problems in solution, as ethylene glycol is extremely hygroscopic. More to the point, there are no published reports (that I have seen, at least) on the long-term effectiveness of ethylene glycol as a preservative or as a component of a preservative. Thus, I would urge EXTREME caution in using it until its effectiveness can be determined.

We have about 300 years experience with ethyl alcohol, and about 100 years with formaldehyde, and there is still a lot we do not know about how the function for fluid fixation and preservation, so I think it is wise to be cautious about switching to new substances without thorough testing and evaluation.

Before using Caro-safe or other proprietary solutions, ask for the MSDS and check it first. Many of these compounds are not much safer than formaldehyde, just less regulated.