atom feed32 messages in org.freebsd.freebsd-currentRe: Current is Really Broken(tm)
FromSent OnAttachments
Alfred PerlsteinSep 23, 1998 1:38 am 
Jordan K. HubbardSep 23, 1998 2:29 am 
Alfred PerlsteinSep 23, 1998 3:42 am 
Peter WemmSep 23, 1998 4:24 am 
Jordan K. HubbardSep 23, 1998 4:35 am 
Bruce EvansSep 23, 1998 5:02 pm 
Terry LambertSep 23, 1998 6:03 pm 
David HollandSep 24, 1998 1:52 pm 
Archie CobbsSep 24, 1998 6:20 pm 
Bruce EvansSep 25, 1998 6:37 pm 
Poul-Henning KampSep 25, 1998 11:31 pm 
Justin T. GibbsSep 26, 1998 9:52 am 
Poul-Henning KampSep 26, 1998 10:32 am 
David HollandSep 26, 1998 7:45 pm 
David HollandSep 26, 1998 8:03 pm 
Poul-Henning KampSep 26, 1998 10:56 pm 
David HollandSep 26, 1998 11:59 pm 
Poul-Henning KampSep 27, 1998 12:21 am 
Greg LeheySep 27, 1998 1:11 am 
Greg LeheySep 27, 1998 1:26 am 
David HollandSep 27, 1998 1:32 am 
Terry LambertSep 27, 1998 1:58 pm 
Terry LambertSep 27, 1998 2:40 pm 
Jeremy LeaSep 28, 1998 7:19 am 
Eivind EklundSep 28, 1998 9:29 am 
Poul-Henning KampSep 28, 1998 10:49 am 
Julian ElischerSep 28, 1998 12:24 pm 
Larry S. LileSep 28, 1998 12:39 pm 
Poul-Henning KampSep 28, 1998 12:51 pm 
Larry S. LileSep 28, 1998 1:56 pm 
Terry LambertSep 28, 1998 4:47 pm 
David HollandSep 28, 1998 4:55 pm 
Subject:Re: Current is Really Broken(tm)
From:Jeremy Lea (re@shale.csir.co.za)
Date:Sep 28, 1998 7:19:30 am
List:org.freebsd.freebsd-current

Hi,

I want to display my complete ignorance and cluelessness (especially with all things related to kernels and devices and booting), by asking a silly question. It's sort of related to this thread but sort of not... well at least I think so.

On Sun, Sep 27, 1998 at 08:59:02PM +0000, Terry Lambert wrote:

Which the kernel has to know anyway, in order to mount things. The structures are there, and they're not going to go away, no matter how ugly their being there is deemed. Well, until we support discardable ELF section tags for unused kernel components.

Why doesn't the kernel always use an MFS as root? I've seen a ton of traffic go by on these lists about the magic needed to mount root partitions, and it would seem to me (in my small mind), that using an MFS, like the boot floppies and PicoBSD, which would always be a `known' quantity, would make a lot of these problems go away.

Maybe it would have to be a special kind of MFS, rootfs, which worked a bit differently to a normally MFS. Maybe it should only be able to hold mount points. Maybe it could be a memory image loaded directly by the boot blocks, which contained the kernel (and maybe lkm's?). Maybe the image could be stored on a DOS (e.g.) partition/slice? Maybe the image could then be used as backing store if the MFS needed it?

Don't laugh, I really don't understand most of this. Don't even understand most of the terms. I just don't like having questions running around in my head...

Regards, -Jeremy

To Unsubscribe: send mail to majo@FreeBSD.org with "unsubscribe freebsd-current" in the body of the message