atom feed61 messages in org.freebsd.freebsd-questionsRe: ip masquerading
FromSent OnAttachments
Clint MarekMay 16, 1996 8:02 pm 
Doug WhiteMay 17, 1996 11:33 am 
Tony KimballMay 17, 1996 2:11 pm 
Terry LambertMay 17, 1996 2:23 pm 
Tony KimballMay 17, 1996 6:04 pm 
Archie CobbsMay 17, 1996 6:05 pm 
Terry LambertMay 17, 1996 6:13 pm 
Tony KimballMay 17, 1996 7:46 pm 
Terry LambertMay 17, 1996 10:48 pm 
Archie CobbsMay 18, 1996 1:23 am 
francis yeungMay 18, 1996 5:26 am 
Bruce A. MahMay 18, 1996 8:43 am 
Eric J. SchwertfegerMay 18, 1996 11:06 am 
Stephen HoveyMay 18, 1996 11:59 am 
Archie CobbsMay 18, 1996 1:05 pm 
Terry LambertMay 18, 1996 3:15 pm 
Clint MarekMay 18, 1996 10:09 pm 
Michael SmithMay 18, 1996 10:36 pm 
Tony KimballMay 19, 1996 12:50 am 
Carl MakinMay 19, 1996 5:01 am 
Pedro A M VazquezMay 19, 1996 6:01 am 
Michael SmithMay 19, 1996 7:40 am 
Charlie ROOTMay 19, 1996 4:37 pm 
Michael SmithMay 19, 1996 7:07 pm 
Garrett WollmanMay 20, 1996 7:40 am 
Bruce A. MahMay 20, 1996 8:37 am 
Tony KimballMay 20, 1996 11:48 am 
Jim DennisMay 20, 1996 12:47 pm 
Garrett WollmanMay 20, 1996 1:29 pm 
Tony KimballMay 20, 1996 1:36 pm 
Terry LambertMay 20, 1996 3:22 pm 
Terry LambertMay 20, 1996 3:28 pm 
Terry LambertMay 20, 1996 3:32 pm 
Gary PalmerMay 20, 1996 3:34 pm 
Archie CobbsMay 20, 1996 3:42 pm 
Terry LambertMay 20, 1996 3:45 pm 
Terry LambertMay 20, 1996 3:56 pm 
Terry LambertMay 20, 1996 4:15 pm 
Tony KimballMay 20, 1996 4:54 pm 
Tony KimballMay 20, 1996 5:09 pm 
Bruce A. MahMay 20, 1996 5:10 pm 
Bruce A. MahMay 20, 1996 5:23 pm 
Tony KimballMay 20, 1996 5:25 pm 
Michael SmithMay 20, 1996 6:38 pm 
Terry LambertMay 20, 1996 6:47 pm 
Jim DennisMay 20, 1996 8:13 pm 
Tony KimballMay 20, 1996 8:24 pm 
Jim DennisMay 20, 1996 9:14 pm 
Terry LambertMay 20, 1996 9:30 pm 
Terry LambertMay 20, 1996 9:34 pm 
Tony KimballMay 20, 1996 10:02 pm 
Bruce A. MahMay 20, 1996 10:12 pm 
Bruce A. MahMay 20, 1996 10:44 pm 
Tony KimballMay 20, 1996 10:47 pm 
M.R.MurphyMay 21, 1996 5:59 am 
Carl MakinMay 21, 1996 6:46 am 
Terry LambertMay 21, 1996 10:40 am 
Terry LambertMay 21, 1996 10:45 am 
Scott BlachowiczMay 22, 1996 9:28 am 
Pedro A M VazquezMay 22, 1996 11:13 am 
Bill FennerMay 22, 1996 11:45 am 
Subject:Re: ip masquerading
From:Garrett Wollman (woll@lcs.mit.edu)
Date:May 20, 1996 1:29:34 pm
List:org.freebsd.freebsd-questions

<<On Mon, 20 May 1996 13:48:49 -0500 (CDT), Tony Kimball <al@Think.COM> said:

Garrett has not spoken yet -- perhaps does not read "questions"? -- but I wonder what his reasons are. I suspect, from other discussion, that the point would be elegance of implementation.

That's pretty close. I don't want the IP processing path cluttered with lots of nasty crap to do fifteen different non-standard actions to every packet (just one---IPFW---is bad enough). Furthermore, implementing something like this would /not/ improve our reputation in the networking research community, and having worked hard to get FreeBSD accepted in one of our current collaborations, our group would not very pleased to say the least.

(Part of my job description is to essentially be a ``mole'' for our corner of the research community to keep things like this from making us look silly.)

So, my position is as follows:

1) If somebody wants to develop a set of patches to implement such functionality in FreeBSD, that's their business.

2) I will remain adamantly opposed to integrating same into the main source base.

-GAWollman