atom feed120 messages in org.freebsd.freebsd-currentRe: Donations.
FromSent OnAttachments
56 earlier messages
John S. DysonMar 4, 1998 1:11 pm 
John S. DysonMar 4, 1998 1:15 pm 
Jordan K. HubbardMar 4, 1998 3:30 pm 
Jordan K. HubbardMar 4, 1998 3:40 pm 
John KellyMar 4, 1998 3:41 pm 
Nate WilliamsMar 4, 1998 3:46 pm 
John KellyMar 4, 1998 3:46 pm 
John KellyMar 4, 1998 3:50 pm 
Mike SmithMar 4, 1998 3:51 pm 
John KellyMar 4, 1998 3:56 pm 
Brian HandyMar 4, 1998 4:02 pm 
John KellyMar 4, 1998 4:02 pm 
Nate WilliamsMar 4, 1998 4:02 pm 
Nate WilliamsMar 4, 1998 4:07 pm 
Mike SmithMar 4, 1998 4:11 pm 
John KellyMar 4, 1998 4:13 pm 
John KellyMar 4, 1998 4:24 pm 
Brian HandyMar 4, 1998 4:29 pm 
John KellyMar 4, 1998 4:30 pm 
Jordan K. HubbardMar 4, 1998 4:32 pm 
Nate WilliamsMar 4, 1998 4:32 pm 
John KellyMar 4, 1998 4:37 pm 
John KellyMar 4, 1998 4:43 pm 
Jordan K. HubbardMar 4, 1998 4:44 pm 
Mike SmithMar 4, 1998 4:50 pm 
John KellyMar 4, 1998 4:51 pm 
John BirrellMar 4, 1998 5:03 pm 
Willem Jan WithagenMar 4, 1998 5:13 pm 
Jordan K. HubbardMar 4, 1998 5:22 pm 
Brian BeattieMar 4, 1998 5:31 pm 
Brian BeattieMar 4, 1998 5:34 pm 
Kris KennawayMar 4, 1998 5:45 pm 
Kyle MesteryMar 4, 1998 6:09 pm 
Michael HancockMar 4, 1998 6:30 pm 
Christopher R. BowmanMar 4, 1998 8:25 pm 
Søren SchmidtMar 4, 1998 11:39 pm 
Tim VanderhoekMar 5, 1998 1:31 am 
Poul-Henning KampMar 5, 1998 1:37 am 
Poul-Henning KampMar 5, 1998 2:07 am 
Amancio HastyMar 5, 1998 2:08 am 
Søren SchmidtMar 5, 1998 2:16 am 
Poul-Henning KampMar 5, 1998 2:31 am 
Amancio HastyMar 5, 1998 2:33 am 
Amancio HastyMar 5, 1998 2:49 am 
Eivind EklundMar 5, 1998 2:54 am 
Mikael KarpbergMar 5, 1998 5:33 am 
John S. DysonMar 5, 1998 8:46 am 
Terry LambertMar 5, 1998 12:29 pm 
Amancio HastyMar 5, 1998 12:50 pm 
Aaron D. GiffordMar 5, 1998 2:51 pm 
Simon ShapiroMar 5, 1998 7:19 pm 
Simon ShapiroMar 5, 1998 7:26 pm 
John S. DysonMar 5, 1998 7:34 pm 
Karl DenningerMar 5, 1998 7:39 pm 
John S. DysonMar 5, 1998 7:46 pm 
Karl DenningerMar 5, 1998 7:57 pm 
Shawn LeasMar 5, 1998 8:00 pm 
Simon ShapiroMar 5, 1998 8:18 pm 
Kevin DayMar 5, 1998 8:28 pm 
Karl DenningerMar 5, 1998 8:38 pm 
Amancio HastyMar 5, 1998 8:38 pm 
Tom BartolMar 5, 1998 11:01 pm 
Brian SomersMar 6, 1998 7:48 am 
Tim VanderhoekMar 6, 1998 12:57 pm 
Subject:Re: Donations.
From:Aaron D. Gifford (agif@infowest.com)
Date:Mar 5, 1998 2:51:53 pm
List:org.freebsd.freebsd-current

Karl Denninger wrote:

On Wed, Mar 04, 1998 at 02:07:29PM +0000, John Kelly wrote:

On Wed, 04 Mar 1998 05:45:23 -0800, "Jordan K. Hubbard" <jk@FreeBSD.ORG> wrote:

With a pool of $500,000 to spend, neither Jordan nor core should be deciding what gets funded. Funding decisions should be controlled by the donors themselves, collectively. And voting is the only way to do that.

This is a complete waste of time. I've already told you - if you have a problem with the way funding is allocated then simply don't donate funds, it's very simple. Can we get back to work now?

Jordan

Keeping my money is one of the easiest things I can do.

If you can't see the value of meaningful donor incentives, someone else will.

Bingo.

MCSNet could make a reasonably-sized donation to this cause (few thousand bucks) and would have no problem with doing so. In fact, if we had some idea what that incremental funding would do, I could make the business case to be significantly more generous. Simply put, money ain't the issue.

The issue is that there are certain things that we really *NEED* fixed, and to stay as priorities in remaining fixed as time goes on (things that used to work, and are now broken for example - specifically, NFS issues for one, and behavior under troublesome SCSI conditions [ie: returns of a defective block from the controller] for another). I'm running kernels and OSs patched up from November, specifically because since then the stability of -CURRENT is bad enough from both direct observation and reports that if the risks grossly outweigh the rewards of trying to roll an upgrade through the network right now.

If I fund the *breakage* of something critical to us, I'm shooting myself in the foot. That's unwise.

I understand that Jordan and the rest of the core team have their own priorities. They sometimes don't mesh with mine. Ok, good and well. I work around what I can, patch around what I can't work around, and remain a few rev levels back if necessary in certain areas. That level of choice is one of the nicities of a free operating system environment with source code in a CVS tree.

But for me to justify shaking loose the money on the tree, I need to be able to show benefit. That's just business - its not personal in any way.

To Unsubscribe: send mail to majo@FreeBSD.org with "unsubscribe freebsd-current" in the body of the message

I have to agree with both sides of this issue. Let me explain.

I believe Jordan's no-strings stand is an absolute necessity for ANY free software non-profit organization that wants to succeed. I believe there are enough folks who contribute freely without being compensated because they enjoy doing so, and I believe many of these same folks would loose motivation to contribute if donations with strings became the norm.

Now I must agree with Karl that for a business (I use FreeBSD where I work too), contributing money WITH strings attached works best for the business and is the best way to encourage larger business donations.

So how would I reconcile these two conflicting interests? Simply. Keep the status quo as far as donations to FreeBSD, Inc., but for ANY and ALL businesses who want specific projects undertaken, get busy and SOLICIT support from OTHER businesses, get together, and FUND development on your project independently, then contribute your work back to FreeBSD if you really believe in the free software model. Otherwise, found another BSDI.

Aaron out.

To Unsubscribe: send mail to majo@FreeBSD.org with "unsubscribe freebsd-current" in the body of the message