11 messages in com.perforce.perforce-user[p4] Question about branching/integra...
FromSent OnAttachments
David Rybolt14 Jun 2004 00:39 
Chuck Karish14 Jun 2004 06:27 
Noel Yap14 Jun 2004 07:37 
David Rybolt14 Jun 2004 11:12 
Dave Lewis14 Jun 2004 12:16 
David Rybolt14 Jun 2004 13:08 
Noel Yap14 Jun 2004 13:13 
Russell C. Jackson14 Jun 2004 14:43 
Dave Lewis14 Jun 2004 18:10 
Chuck Karish15 Jun 2004 09:31 
ste...@vance.com16 Jun 2004 19:11 
Subject:[p4] Question about branching/integrating
From:David Rybolt (da@yahoo.com)
Date:06/14/2004 12:39:13 AM
List:com.perforce.perforce-user

Hello,

I regularly run into this branching conundrum, and was wondering if anyone had any suggestions.

My current directory structure looks something like this (only showing relevant directories):

//depot/project/main/... //depot/project/releases/4.1.0/...

The 4.1.0 directory was branched from main about 3 weeks ago, and both main and 4.1.0 have had checkins since the branch.

This was working great for a while. I'd merge the 4.1.0 code back into main as necessary, and everything was good. However, now my developers want to start checking in new code for a new release, but they don't know if it'll actually go to production before or after the code in my mainline.

Any suggestions?

Here is what I can't do:

1. Branch from main, because I might not want a lot of the recent main code.

2. I can't branch from the 4.1.0 branch, because merging it back into main would be a pain.

Thanks for your help, Dave