38 messages in com.xensource.lists.xen-develRe: [Xen-devel] Re: [PATCH] Xen Guest...
FromSent OnAttachments
Mark Williamson07 Jul 2005 10:16 
Eric W. Biederman08 Jul 2005 01:59 
Mark Williamson08 Jul 2005 07:35 
Mark Williamson08 Jul 2005 10:34 
Horms23 Feb 2006 02:52 
Gerd Hoffmann23 Feb 2006 03:21 
Mark Williamson23 Feb 2006 03:32 
Mark Williamson23 Feb 2006 03:36 
Gerd Hoffmann23 Feb 2006 05:03 
Mark Williamson23 Feb 2006 06:49 
Gerd Hoffmann24 Feb 2006 06:35 
Ian Pratt26 Feb 2006 14:49 
Horms26 Feb 2006 19:31 
Keir Fraser26 Feb 2006 23:10 
Mark Williamson27 Feb 2006 06:28 
Mark Williamson27 Feb 2006 06:58 
Gerd Hoffmann27 Feb 2006 07:34 
Gerd Hoffmann27 Feb 2006 07:39 
Keir Fraser27 Feb 2006 08:19 
Gerd Hoffmann01 Mar 2006 04:08.oops
Gerd Hoffmann01 Mar 2006 06:09 
Keir Fraser01 Mar 2006 07:02 
Keir Fraser01 Mar 2006 09:35 
Gerd Hoffmann02 Mar 2006 01:16 
Keir Fraser02 Mar 2006 01:43 
Gerd Hoffmann02 Mar 2006 03:34.oops
Keir Fraser02 Mar 2006 03:55 
Gerd Hoffmann02 Mar 2006 08:35 
Keir Fraser02 Mar 2006 08:47 
Gerd Hoffmann03 Mar 2006 00:39 
Keir Fraser03 Mar 2006 01:14 
Keir Fraser03 Mar 2006 01:35 
Gerd Hoffmann03 Mar 2006 03:19 
Gerd Hoffmann06 Mar 2006 06:14 
Michael Vrable06 Mar 2006 08:03 
Gerd Hoffmann07 Mar 2006 05:05 
Keir Fraser07 Mar 2006 05:41 
Gerd Hoffmann07 Mar 2006 06:42.oops
Subject:Re: [Xen-devel] Re: [PATCH] Xen Guest Kexec
From:Horms (hor@verge.net.au)
Date:02/26/2006 07:31:58 PM
List:com.xensource.lists.xen-devel

On Thu, Feb 23, 2006 at 11:36:36AM +0000, Mark Williamson wrote:

I have been looking into various crash-dump options, and with that in mind, exploring kexec for Dom0. I'm wondering if the patch above is still the latest, and if this is still the prefered approach for kexec in Dom0.

My patch was out-of-tree so it's rotted. I've been waiting for various other things to get sorted before it's worth updating it again (updating to a kernel that actually has the kexec system call, one or two other patches).

Could you be a little more specific about that. I am pretty interested in getting this working. As far as I understand Xen is now running on 2.6.16-rc4 which does have kexec. I'm happy to put some cycles into updating the patch, though I must confess I am quite interested in Gerd's approach which is closer to what I was originally thinking.

The patch wouldn't allow kexec for dom0 anyhow. Enabling kdump for dom0 would be useful. I think there was somebody considering looking at this in the future...

Understood. I was only talking of DomU with regards to the assisted kexec patch that you sent earlier. I am also intersted in getting kexec working in Dom0, however I agree with Gerd's statements elsewhere in this thread that it can be acchived by porting kexec to Xen (or as I understand it given the current state of kexec, teaching kexec a few things about Xen in the prevailing architecture).

I'm actually quite interested in getting both kexec and kdump working on both DomU and Dom0. I understand that for the most port there are really four different problems there. I'd really like to help out with existing efforts to help get all or any of them working.

For now I'm going to poke around with Gerd's idea of asking xend to do system dumps for crash analysis of DomU, as that seems to be an area of little activity at this time.